Subway Tile Kitchen Remodel
A Villanova peninsula-to-island rebuild with white Shaker frameless cabinets, classic subway tile in dark grout, and a beadboard-back island.
Project Specs
| Town | Villanova, PA |
|---|---|
| Cabinetry | White Shaker frameless cabinets, full perimeter and island; beadboard backer panel on the back of the island |
| Countertops | Quartz — white/grey veined, same material on perimeter and island |
| Range | Stainless slide-in electric range |
| Range Hood | Stainless pro-style chimney wall hood |
| Sink | Fireclay farmhouse apron-front under the window |
| Backsplash | Classic white subway tile in running bond with dark grout — the defining design choice |
| Architectural | Original peninsula removed and replaced with a parallel island; tray ceiling retained; existing windows retained |
| Flooring | Dark stained hardwood |
| Hardware | Polished nickel bin pulls on drawers, knobs on doors |
| Lighting | New recessed general lighting, two black industrial caged-lantern pendants over the island, under-cabinet lighting |
| Style | Modern farmhouse / classic transitional |
About This Kitchen
The most common older-home remodel request we get in Villanova and the Main Line is some version of the peninsula-to-island conversion. The 1990s and early-2000s builder kitchen almost always pairs a peninsula with seating on one side, a chandelier above it, and a wall that limits sightlines into the breakfast room. This was that kitchen.
The peninsula came out. A parallel island went in. The seating moved from side-by-side along one edge to a proper two-sided arrangement around the new island. The square footage is the same. The kitchen reads twice as large.
The defining material choice is the dark grout on the classic white subway tile. Most homeowners default to matching grout because it photographs cleaner. Dark grout adds about 40% more visual impact for the same tile cost. The honest tradeoff: it hides kitchen grease, but it shows hard-water spotting on the grout itself, so countertop habits matter more. The beadboard panel on the back of the island is the second farmhouse signal — small detail that turns a working island into something that feels built rather than installed.
What we tell clients planning a peninsula-to-island conversion: do the seating math first. A peninsula seats two side-by-side; a proper island seats three to four around two sides. The conversation around the island is the actual upgrade — the layout change is what pays for the project, not the new tile.
After
Before
Free Download
2026 Southeastern PA Kitchen & Bath Remodeling Cost Guide
A complete cost reference for Chester County, Delaware County, and the Main Line. Inside: real 2026 ranges for every kitchen and bathroom tier — from a $30K cosmetic refresh to a $150K+ custom build, plus what drives high-end versus low-end pricing, what’s included at each level, and the cost factors most homeowners overlook before they sign.
Get the full guide
See what every kitchen and bathroom tier actually costs in our service area — with line-item breakdowns from completed Fedor projects in West Chester, Exton, Wayne, and Malvern.
Free PDF · No spam · Unsubscribe anytime
Want to talk about your kitchen project?
Free in-home consultation. We come out, look at your actual house, and walk you through what is possible — design, selections, fixed-price proposal. No high-pressure pitch.
Or call 610-431-7150